IRS Offer in Compromise Attorney in New Jersey & New York

An IRS Offer in Compromise (OIC) may allow a qualifying taxpayer to settle their tax debt for less than the full balance owed. However, an offer approval is not automatic, easy, or appropriate for every financial situation.

The IRS rigorously audits income, assets, household expenses, asset equity, filing compliance, and overall collection potential. Todd S. Unger, Esq. helps individuals and businesses evaluate whether an Offer in Compromise is realistic before submitting paperwork to the IRS.

Request a Consultation

Call (877) 544-4743

Can You Settle IRS Tax Debt for Less Than You Owe?

An IRS Offer in Compromise is a formal administrative agreement between a taxpayer and the Internal Revenue Service that resolves a tax liability for less than the full amount owed. In doubt-as-to-collectibility cases, the IRS evaluates whether the taxpayer can fully pay the balance from available assets, current disposable income, and future earning potential.

The offer amount submitted generally must equal or exceed what the IRS calculates as your Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP).

Many taxpayers apply prematurely, offer arbitrary settlement numbers, or fail to account for IRS financial standards. Todd S. Unger helps evaluate your eligibility before you file, ensuring you understand both the strategic opportunities and procedural risks.

Tax attorney reviewing IRS Offer in Compromise financial documents with a client

Who May Qualify for an IRS Offer in Compromise?

An Offer in Compromise should be evaluated when your back taxes cannot be resolved through full payment, an ordinary installment agreement, or other administrative programs. Qualification relies strictly on verifiable financial facts:

You cannot realistically pay the full IRS balance before statutory collection periods expire

Your disposable income and asset equity are limited relative to total tax debt

You are fully compliant with all required prior tax return filings

You cannot resolve the tax debt through a structured installment agreement

Full collection would create severe economic hardship under IRS standards

There is a legitimate legal dispute regarding the validity or amount of the tax debt

An Offer in Compromise is only one tool in tax resolution. Depending on your situation, an IRS installment agreement, penalty abatement, or bringing back taxes and unfiled tax returns into compliance may serve as a superior first step.

Three Main Grounds for an Offer in Compromise

Taxpayers can petition for an Offer in Compromise under three distinct legal categories:

1. Doubt as to Liability

Applies when a genuine legal or factual dispute exists regarding whether the assessed tax liability is correct under tax law. This category focuses on proving the assessment is wrong rather than proving financial hardship.

2. Doubt as to Collectibility

The most common category. Applies when the tax debt is legally valid, but the taxpayer’s total net asset equity and projected disposable future income are insufficient to pay the balance in full before statutory collection periods expire.

3. Effective Tax Administration (ETA)

Applies in exceptional situations where the tax debt could technically be collected in full, but full collection would cause severe economic hardship or prove grossly unfair and inequitable due to extraordinary circumstances (e.g., severe illness or disability).

Schedule a meeting with New Jersey tax attorney Todd Unger for IRS tax help

Understanding Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP)

Reasonable Collection Potential is the mathematical formula the IRS uses to calculate the minimum acceptable settlement amount. RCP includes the net realizable value of your assets (real estate, bank accounts, retirement funds, vehicles) plus your calculated future monthly disposable income over a 12- or 24-month multiplier.

An offer is not simply asking the IRS for a discount. Success relies on substantiating through strict financial documentation why your true Reasonable Collection Potential is lower than your total assessed tax liability.

Todd S. Unger conducts a comprehensive financial analysis prior to filing, ensuring your submission aligns with official IRS financial standards while avoiding unnecessary rejections.

What Financial Records the IRS Audits

An Offer in Compromise requires complete financial transparency. Examiners scrutinize your complete financial profile on Form 433-OIC:

Monthly Income & Earning Capacity

Bank Balances & Liquid Cash Assets

Real Estate Equity & Vehicle Values

Business Accounts & Receivables

Allowable Necessary Household Expenses

Current Tax Filing & Deposit Compliance

IRS Form 433 Financial Statements for Offer in Compromise evaluation

Mandatory Tax Filing Compliance

The IRS will immediately return an Offer in Compromise application without review if you have unfiled tax returns or fail to make required current estimated tax payments or payroll tax deposits.

If missing returns are part of your case, bringing back taxes and unfiled tax returns current is the mandatory first phase of our legal representation.

Experienced tax controversy attorney assisting clients with IRS debt settlement

Application Fees & Offer Payment Structures

Submitting an OIC requires a $205 application fee plus an initial payment, unless you qualify for the IRS Low-Income Certification threshold based on household size and income.

Taxpayers choose between two payment structures: a Lump Sum Cash Offer (20% paid with application, remainder paid in 5 or fewer payments upon acceptance) or a Periodic Payment Offer (initial payment submitted with application, remaining balance paid in monthly installments over 6 to 24 months while under review).

What Happens During and After an Offer in Compromise?

1. While the Offer Is Pending

The IRS reviews financial records and verifies compliance. Active levies are typically suspended, but the 10-year collection statute of limitations is paused (tolled) during review plus 30 days.

2. After Offer Acceptance

You must pay the agreed settlement amount under the terms and maintain strict tax filing and payment compliance for 5 consecutive years. Defaulting on future tax filings revokes the compromise and reinstates original liabilities.

3. After Rejection or Return

If rejected, you have 30 days to file a formal administrative appeal with the Office of Appeals, transition to an installment agreement, or pursue penalty relief.

Looking for a deeper educational overview of the OIC process? Read our detailed guide: What Is an IRS Offer in Compromise?

An Offer in Compromise Is Not Right for Everyone

Despite national TV advertisements, the IRS rejects a majority of unrepresented OIC filings. Submitting a weak offer wastes time, extends IRS collection windows, and exposes your financial accounts to unnecessary scrutiny.

When an Offer May Not Fit

• The IRS calculates you can pay full debt via installment plan

• You have asset equity (real estate, 401k) the IRS expects you to liquidate

• Your prior tax return filings are not up to date

• Filing pauses statutory collection windows on older tax debts

Why Legal Review Matters

An OIC impacts collection timelines, requires financial disclosure, and can create issues if bankruptcy or partial-payment installment agreements are better alternatives.

At the Law Office of Todd S. Unger, Esq., LLC, we evaluate your complete picture to determine the optimal legal resolution.

Review Your Options

Our Offer in Compromise Legal Process

1. Audit the Complete Tax History

We analyze IRS account transcripts, notice histories, collection status, asset valuations, allowable expenses, and statutory collection end dates.

2. Calculate True Reasonable Collection Potential

Before filing, Todd S. Unger determines whether financial facts support an offer or if an installment plan or penalty relief is a superior remedy.

3. Prepare & Submit Documented Package

If an offer is viable, we assemble Form 656 and Form 433-OIC with legal narratives and financial substantiation designed to withstand IRS examination.

4. Advocate & Protect Long-Term Goals

We negotiate directly with IRS Offer Examiners and protect your interests across liens, appeals, and prospective compliance obligations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to common questions regarding IRS Offer in Compromise qualification and debt settlement.

Can the IRS really settle tax debt for less than owed?

Yes. Congress authorized the IRS to settle tax debts via an Offer in Compromise when the taxpayer meets strict statutory criteria and the offer represents the maximum amount collectibility calculations support.

What does the IRS look at when evaluating an offer?

The IRS audits income, liquid assets, asset equity, allowable living expenses, filing history, and future earning potential to establish your Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP).

Is an Offer in Compromise better than an installment agreement?

An Offer in Compromise is superior if you qualify because it settles the debt permanently. However, if your asset equity or disposable income proves you can pay the full liability over time, an installment plan is the realistic path.

What is Doubt as to Liability?

Doubt as to Liability applies when there is a genuine dispute over whether the tax debt is legally owed or whether the assessed amount is correct under tax law.

What is Doubt as to Collectibility?

Doubt as to Collectibility applies when the tax debt is valid, but your assets and future income are insufficient to pay the full balance before the statutory collection period expires.

Can a business apply for an Offer in Compromise?

Yes. Operating businesses can petition for an OIC, but must maintain current filing compliance and remain current with ongoing employment tax deposits during review.

What happens if the IRS rejects my offer?

You have 30 days to appeal the rejection to the IRS Office of Appeals. If the rejection stands, you can negotiate an installment agreement, request Currently Not Collectible status, or explore penalty abatement.

Should I apply for an Offer in Compromise myself?

Filing without legal analysis carries risk. Unrepresented filings often contain errors that cause rejections and extend the 10-year collection statute. A tax attorney ensures your numbers are defensible before submission.

Find Out Whether an Offer in Compromise Is Realistic

Before submitting an offer to the IRS, ensure the financial numbers support your case. Work directly with tax attorney Todd S. Unger to evaluate your tax resolution options.